Friday, December 8, 2023

The Secret History of Yoga: Unmasking the Myths and Reclaiming Its Roots

 

Unveiling Yoga’s Hidden History: A Decolonized Journey Through Time

Introduction: The Myth vs. The Mosaic

The dominant narrative paints yoga as a 5,000-year-old, monolithic Hindu practice—but the truth is far richer. Yoga’s history is a living tapestry woven from Indigenous rituals, tantric rebellion, colonial adaptation, and modern reclamation. This article dismantles myths to reveal yoga’s multicultural, contested, and ever-evolving origins.

Key Controversy:

  • A 2023 Oxford University Press study argues that pre-Vedic Indus Valley seals (c. 2600 BCE) depicting meditative figures suggest yoga predates Hinduism.

  • Colonial-era texts erased contributions from Dalit, Buddhist, and tribal communities to fit Eurocentric ideals of "spirituality."

Yoga origin

1. Beyond India’s Borders: Yoga’s Forgotten Ancestors

A. The Indus Valley Connection: Proto-Yoga?

  • Artifact Evidence: Seals from Mohenjo-Daro show figures in Mulabandhasana (root lock pose), hinting at early somatic practices.

  • Tribal Integration: Indigenous Dravidian traditions likely contributed ecstatic dance (later mirrored in Kundalini’s serpentine movements).

Scholarly Debate:

  • Historian Dr. James Mallinson (SOAS) notes: *"What we call ‘yoga’ today is a 19th-century synthesis of asceticism, Sufi breathwork, and British gymnastics."*

B. Buddhist & Jain Threads: The Silent Shapers

  • Jainism’s Legacy: The Kayotsarga (meditative standing posture) directly influenced modern Tadasana (Mountain Pose).

  • Buddhist Vipassana: The satipatthana (mindfulness) framework became central to yoga’s dhyana (meditation) limb.

Lost History:

  • Medieval Jain texts like the Yogasastra (c. 12th century) describe 84 asanas—centuries before Hatha Yoga’s codification.

2. Tantra’s Revolution: The Birth of Physical Yoga

A. The Tantric Underground (5th–10th Century CE)

  • Radical Shift: Tantra rejected Vedic elitism, declaring the body as sacred. Its practices fused:

    • Shamanic rituals (Bhuta Shuddhi)

    • Erotic mysticism (Maithuna as spiritual union)

    • Hatha Yoga’s precursor: Vigorous kriyas (cleansing techniques)

Taboo Truth:

  • Early Hatha yogis were outcasts—practicing in cremation grounds to defy Brahminical purity laws.

B. The Colonial Erasure of Tantra

  • British Victorians labeled Tantra as "degenerate," pushing yogis like Ramakrishna to sanitize yoga for export.

people practising tantric yoga

3. Swami Vivekananda & the Yoga Renaissance

A. The 1893 Chicago Lecture That Rewrote History

Swami Vivekananda photo
  • Vivekananda’s Neo-Vedanta presentation at the World’s Parliament of Religions:

    • Erased Tantra’s bodily focus, rebranding yoga as "pure philosophy."

    • Appealed to Western tastes by framing yoga as "science," not ritual.

Irony: His Raja Yoga (1896) borrowed heavily from Western New Thought movements, not ancient texts.

B. The Gymnastics Influence

  • Danish drills (introduced by British colonizers) were reinterpreted as "asanas" by early 20th-century yogis like Krishnamacharya.


Modern yoga place

4. Modern Yoga: Colonial Legacies & Corporate Takeovers

A. B.K.S. Iyengar’s Standardization

  • Medicalized Yoga: Iyengar’s Light on Yoga (1966) reframed poses as therapeutic tools, divorcing them from spiritual context.

  • Patent Wars: Over 130 US yoga-related patents exist—a stark contrast to yoga’s oral, communal origins.

B. The Brahminical Stranglehold

  • Caste Barriers: Less than 3% of globally recognized yoga teachers are Dalit or Adivasi (Yoga Alliance India, 2022).

  • Cultural Appropriation: The $90 billion wellness industry profits from desacralized yoga.

5. Reclamation & Revolution: Yoga’s Future

A. Decolonizing the Mat

  • Dalit Yoga Movements: Groups like Yoga For Equality teach Ambedkarite yoga, centering anti-caste values.

  • Indigenous Revival: Adivasi communities in Odisha practice Dongria Kondh yoga, blending forest wisdom with asana.

B. Accessibility as Justice

  • Pay-What-You-Can Studios (e.g., The Underbelly in NYC) challenge corporate studio elitism.

  • Disability-Inclusive Yoga: Chair yoga and proprioceptive cues for neurodivergent practitioners.

Conclusion: Yoga Is a Mirror of Power

Yoga’s history is not a linear ascent but a battleground of power, erasure, and resilience. To honor its roots:

  1. Credit marginalized voices (e.g., Tamil Siddhars, Buddhist nuns).

  2. Reject cultural amnesia—practice with historical awareness.

  3. Fight for equity—support grassroots yoga teachers of color.

"Yoga doesn’t belong to any one tradition—it belongs to all who seek liberation."
—Dr. Anandra George, Decolonizing Yoga (2021)


FAQs: Facing the Hard Questions

Q1: Did yoga really originate in the Indus Valley?
A: Evidence is circumstantial—seals suggest proto-yogic practices, but no continuous lineage exists.

Q2: Why don’t modern yoga classes discuss caste?
A: Brahminical gatekeeping suppressed yoga’s radical, anti-caste history.

Q3: How can I practice yoga ethically?
A: Learn from Dalit/BIPOC teachers, pay fairly, and acknowledge yoga’s socio-political context.